Um, and some more TNG commentary. Because apparently I'm some how not asleep.
( Angel One (1x14) )( 11001001 (1x15) )( Too Short a Season (1x16) )( When the Bough Breaks (1x17) )( Home Soil (1x18) )( Coming of Age (1x19) )( Heart of Glory (1x20) )( The Arsenal of Freedom (1x21) )So, a moment on Tasha Yar. My thirteen-year-old sister's best friend likes her best, except for in "The Naked Now," which, according to A., reveals that "she secretly just wants to be a big slut." Internally, I was torn between horror and
total hilarity when I heard this solemn pronouncement, but it made me think about that episode and about some of my issues with Yar. I do not give a flying fuck about what kind of sex Yar wants to be having, but, despite enjoying her scenes in that episode, they compounded my feelings that she is...immature. She reads as extremely adolescent to me, especially there: she seems so basically insecure about her femininity and sexuality, just slightly
awkward. Her not-intoxicated approach to sex seems to be a sort of gruffness or feigned disinterest over thinly veiled curiosity. (Not always, but often enough -- for both examples and counterexamples see "Justice.")
In her approach to her job, she is, okay, more competent than I allowed above (I am just so amused by her complete lack of anything resembling tact), but she is so brash and unthinking, having to be reprimanded by the Captain when she's blatantly out of line or, bizarrely, just being given free rein to EXPRESS HER UTTER LACK OF TACT. "You eat
that?" "You're secure enough to wear a
robe?" It's like being saddled with a -- extremely fit and tactically intelligent -- sixteen-year-old. Maybe the rape gangs (oh god that expression again) made her grow up more quickly, but I think living on the streets also stunted her emotional growth.
Anyway. I am entertained by Yar's diplomatic fail, I am impressed by her martial skills, and I would like to like her, but in a show where the fifteen-year-old routinely saves the day, I am frustrated by her lack of maturity.